This article critiques the historical narrative of the Gilbert & Marshall Islands Campaign during World War 2, arguing that the official accounts are exaggerated and potentially fabricated. The author questions the stated casualty figures, the feasibility of the battles given the small size of the islands, and the photographic evidence, suggesting many images are staged or manipulated. The campaign, spanning from August 1942 to February 1944, involved operations like Operation Galvanic, Operation Kourbash, Operation Flintlock, and Operation Catchpole, aimed at securing airfields and naval bases from Japanese occupiers. Key battles discussed include Tarawa, Makin, Kwajalein, Eniwetok, and Majuro. The author highlights inconsistencies in troop numbers, defensive fortifications, and the nature of the fighting, proposing that many depicted events were actually military drills or staged scenarios. Specific points of contention include the Battle of Tarawa’s logistical failures, the effectiveness of naval bombardments, the appearance of corpses, and the supposed fanatical resistance of the Japanese forces. The article concludes that the war’s portrayal is suspect, with a focus on creating a dramatic narrative rather than adhering to factual accounts.
Here’s a breakdown of the entities mentioned:
People:
- Lestrade aka Unpopular Opinion (Author)
- General Douglas MacArthur
- United States Navy Admiral Chester W. Nimitz
- Carlson’s Raiders
- Rear Admiral Keiji Shibazaki
- Prince Kuni Asaakira
- Emperor Shōwa (Hirohito)
- Zola De Haven
- Miles
- Colonel David Shoup
- Major Frank Holland
- General Holland Smith
- General Alexander Vandegrift
- Staff Sgt Norman T. Hatch
- Miles
- Cuba Gooding Jr.
- Sullivan Brothers
- William J. Woodward Jr.
- Admiral Akiyama Monzō
- Vice Admiral Koso Abe
- General Nishida
- Colonel John T. Walker
- Colonel Ayers
- Lt Col. Hashida Masahiro
- Colonel Toshio Yano
- Lt. Hand
- Captain Jones
- Lt. Silverthorn
- Lt. Corey
- John Woods
Locations:
- Gilbert & Marshall Islands
- United Kingdom (UK)
- South Pacific
- Kiribati
- Tarawa
- Makin
- Kwajalein
- Eniwetok
- Majuro
- White House
- Philippines
- New Guinea
- China
- Aleutians
- Soviet Union
- India
- South Asia
- California
- Hawaii
- Australia
- New Zealand
- Butaritari
- Betio
- Guadalcanal
- Tulagi
- The Heisei Emperor
- Indiana
- Iceland
- Rabaul
- Gettysburg
- Pearl Harbour
- Yap, Federated States of Micronesia
- Parry Island
- Medren (Parry Island’s current name)
- Japtan
Military Operations/Battles:
- Pacific Theatre
- Gilbert & Marshall Island Campaign
- World War 2
- Operation Galvanic
- Operation Kourbash
- Battle of Tarawa
- Battle of Makin
- Operation Flintlock
- Operation Catchpole
- Carlson’s Raiders’ diversionary Raid on Makin Island
- Battle of Makin Island (November 20–24, 1943)
- Battle of Kwajalein (January 31 – February 3, 1944)
- Battle of Apamama (August 1942)
- Battle of Eniwetok (February 17–23, 1944)
Companies/Organizations/Entities:
- Call of Duty
- History Channel
- United States Pacific Fleet
- Marine Corps
- Japanese Imperial Navy
- ONI (Office of Naval Intelligence)
- Pentagon
- Warner Bros
- Office of War Information
- League of Nations
- Imperial General Headquarters
- United States Army
- United States Navy
- German Empire
- Japanese
References/Publications:
Military Equipment/Terms:
- Iron Man robot suits
- Amphibious landings
- Booby traps
- Minefields
- Banzai suicide rushes
- Higgins boats
- Reef
- Landing Vehicles (LVTs) / Alligators
- Pillboxes / Stockades
- Vickers 8-inch guns
- Russo-Japanese War
- Aircraft carriers (CVs, CVLs, CVEs)
- Battleships
- Heavy cruisers
- Light cruisers
- Destroyers
- Transport ships
- Monster Energy drink
- Kaigun Taii (lieutenant)
- Kaigun Shōsa (lieutenant-commander)
- Neap tide
- Spring tides
- Sea wall
- Medal of Honor
- British Distinguished Service Order
- Rocket-propelled grenade (RPG)
- Samurai sword
- Ha-Go tank
- Douglas SBD Dauntless dive bombers
- Vought F4U Corsairs
- Grumman TBM Avengers
- Curtiss SB2C Helldivers
- North American B-25 Mitchells
- Curtiss C-46 Commandos
- Grumman F4F Wildcats
- Type 95 light tanks
- F6F Hellcat
- VF-12
- USS Tennessee
- B-24 bombers
- Carlson island
- USS Baltimore
- USS Mississippi
- USS Liscome Bay
- I-175 (Japanese submarine)
- USS New Mexico
- USS Coral Sea
- Grumman FM-1 Wildcat fighters
- Grumman F4F Wildcat fighters
- USS Hollister (DD-788)
- USS Miller (FF-1091)
- USS Doris Miller (CVN-81)
- USS Mullinnix (DD-944)
- USS Wiltsie (DD-716)
- Makin Lagoon
- USS Colorado
- USS Maryland
- USS Pennsylvania
- USS Louisville
- USS Phelps (DD-360)
- USS Tennessee
- USS Pennsylvania
- Destroyer USS Hailey
- 104th Field Artillery
- 2nd Separate Pack Howitzer Battalions
- Douglas SBD Dauntless dive bombers
- Vought F4U Corsairs
- Grumman TBF Avengers
- Curtiss SB2C Helldivers
- North American B-25 Mitchells
- Curtiss C-46 Commandos
- Grumman F4F Wildcats
- USS Indianapolis
- TNT
- Japanese propaganda
- Pickett’s Charge
- USS Dashiell
- USS Ringgold
Other:
- Atoll (used humorously due to the prompt’s instruction)
- WW2
- Pickett’s Charge at Gettysburg
- Summer Holiday Outro Music
- Movie
- YouTube
- Newsreel
- Dog tags
- Order of the Golden Kite, 4th class
- Nuclear bombs
- Nuremberg trials