This article argues that the Natalee Holloway case is a staged event, part of a larger project called Men-are-Pigs designed to scare women and divide the sexes. The author, Miles Mathis, claims everyone involved is an agent from connected families, and no one actually died. Holloway allegedly joined the CIA as a cover, and the story was later expanded for the Men-are-Pigs project, becoming a persistent news item to distract from real issues. Mathis points to inconsistencies in the narratives surrounding Holloway’s disappearance and the subsequent legal proceedings involving Joran van der Sloot.

Key points highlighted by Mathis include:

  • Both Natalee Holloway and Joran van der Sloot were high-achieving students and athletes, suggesting recruitment potential. Holloway’s stepfather, George Twitty, is a wealthy businessman from Mountain Brook, Alabama.
  • The graduation attire at Mountain Brook High School is noted as a discrepancy.
  • Joran van der Sloot’s father, Paulus van der Sloot, was a wealthy lawyer with alleged ties to Dutch Intelligence. His quick rise to partner in a law firm after suing the government is presented as a clue.
  • Paulus van der Sloot’s supposed death by heart attack at age 57 while playing tennis is questioned, with Mathis suggesting it was faked to avoid “theater” in Peru.
  • The rapid identification of Joran van der Sloot by Beth Holloway (Natalee Holloway’s mother) and her stepfather within four hours of arriving in Aruba is deemed impossible and indicative of a pre-arranged scenario.
  • The account of Beth Holloway and George Twitty going directly to Joran van der Sloot’s house with police is dismissed as against protocol.
  • The existence of Holiday Inn videotape showing Joran and Natalee together is questioned, with Beth Holloway later admitting Natalee was not on hotel video.
  • The extensive search efforts, including the day off for civil servants in Aruba and donations from Aruban banks, are presented as unusual for a missing person case.
  • Joran van der Sloot’s 2010 jailing in Peru for the murder of Stephany Flores, daughter of Peruvian presidential candidate Ricardo Flores, is seen as a fabricated event. Mathis notes the anniversary of Holloway’s disappearance and the date of Flores’s murder (May 30) as significant.
  • Stephany Flores was allegedly killed with a tennis racket, a sport Joran played.
  • The evidence found with Joran after Flores’s murder, including bloody clothes and ocean current charts, is presented as deliberately planted.
  • The idea that Stephany Flores’s body needed exhumation for fingernail DNA is dismissed.
  • Joran’s placement in a high-security prison in Peru, yet seemingly being able to give interviews to the press, is flagged as impossible.
  • A photo of Joran with other inmates, Hugo Trujillo Ospina and William Trickett Smith II, is analyzed as a composite, with inconsistencies in prison attire and security.
  • Beth Holloway and Peter de Vries’s alleged confrontation with Joran in prison is presented as CIA fiction, questioning how they gained access and obtained footage.
  • Joran’s 2014 marriage to Leidy Figueroa in prison and the birth of their child are described as a “pathetic attempt” to explain a child, with Mathis claiming convicted murderers don’t have conjugal visits. The idea of female vendors in a maximum-security prison is also questioned.
  • A video of Joran involved in a marijuana transaction within the prison is called a staged event.
  • Mathis suggests Natalee Holloway appears older in her senior graduation photo than her reported age of 18, and searches for individuals named Natalee yield no matches, except for a Natalee Ann Cole and a Hollowell who appears to be 24 in 2005.
  • Genealogical research links Beth Holloway to the Reynolds family (tobacco and aluminum), and to the Fahnestock banking family, who are connected to Chase National Bank and Rockefellers. This is contrasted with a supposedly fabricated Reynolds genealogy.
  • The Nichols family, to which Beth’s mother Ann Nichols belonged, is also linked to powerful families and the founding of New York.
  • Gerold Dompig, former deputy chief of police in Aruba, is mentioned in the Paradise Papers and founded a company called Shield, possibly involved in money laundering. His son worked for the same security firm as Geoffrey van Cromvoirt, who was arrested and whose sister allegedly appeared in a reenactment of Holloway’s “kidnapping.”
  • The Holloway case is presented as a diversionary tactic, an “eyes off project” to cover financial machinations.
  • Mathis calls for readers to question and educate others about these staged events, emphasizing that once people know, the “old tricks won’t work anymore.”
  • A recent (October 18, 2023) update details Van der Sloot’s alleged release from Peru, return to the US for extortion charges, and a guilty plea admitting to Holloway’s murder. Mathis dismisses this as further “fear porn” and legally absurd.

List of Subjects, Names, References, Locations, Companies, etc.: